As part of the GOP's all-out-effort to repeal health care reform, the Club For Growth is asking lawmakers and candidates in the 2010 elections to "pledge to the people of my district/state to sponsor and support legislation to repeal any federal health care takeover passed in 2010, and replace it with real reforms that lower health care costs without growing government." At least 17 lawmakers and 36 candidates have signed onto the repeal, including Florida "Tea Party" candidate Marco Rubio. "The proposed government takeover of health care being rammed through Congress runs contrary to the principles of limited government that have made Americans the freest and most prosperous people ever," Rubio said:
Quote:
As a U.S. senator, I will sponsor and support legislation to repeal any federal health care takeover passed in 2010, and replace it with real reforms that lower health care costs without growing government. This is not just about simply opposing and repealing the Obama-Reid-Pelosi agenda. This is about putting America back on a limited government track. This will require opposing new spending binges, but also turning back some of the mistakes made by President Obama and this Congress, including the pending health care bill."
Unfortunately, Rubio's arguments against reform are as specious as his "constitutionality" claims. The Congressional Budget Office has concluded that reform would result in "no significant change" in the federal government's commitment to health care, and constitutional scholars from across the country argue that the Commerce Clause "permits Congress to regulate commerce, or actions that directly affect economic activity," such as requiring Americans to purchase health insurance coverage.
The GOP's health care industry-funded constitutional push is designed to attract campaign cash and get-out-the vote, but should their efforts succeed, the "pledging lawmakers" would be undermining the interests of their constituents. After all, the CBO has estimated that reform would insure as many as 31 million Americans and lower premiums for subsidized Americans in the exchange. A back-of-the envelope analysis conducted by ThinkProgress reveals that on average, the constituencies of the lawmakers and candidates who have signed the Club For Growth's repeal pledge, have experienced higher than average premium increases, rates of uninsurance and annual percent growth in health care expenditures and insurance market concentration:
House lawmakers/candidates petition signers
| Rate Of Uninsurance (2008) | Annual Growth (2008) | Increase In Premiums 2000-2007 | Top 2 Insurers | Lawmaker/ candidate | District |
U.S. average | 15.4% | 6.7% | 120% | N/A | | |
Texas | 25.2% | 7.4% | 87% | 68% | Kenny Marchant | TX-24 |
New Mexico | 23.2% | 7.2% | 92% | 65% | Adam Kokesh | NM-3 |
Florida | 20.2% | 7.1% | 72% | 45% | Steve Southerland | FL-2 |
Gus Bilirakis | FL-9 |
Kansas | 17.8% | 6.4% | 88% | 56% | Jerry Moran | KS-1 |
Tim Huelskamp | KS-1 |
Lynn Jenkins | KS-2 |
Todd Tiahrt | KS-4 |
Patricia Lightner | KS-3 |
Louisiana | 19.3% | 5.7% | 75% | 74% | Steve Scalise | LA-1 |
Arizona | 18.9% | 7.7% | 81% | 65% | Eric Wnuck | AZ-5 |
Jeff Flake | AZ-6 |
Colorado | 16.2% | 7.7% | 75% | 53% | Doug Lamborn | CO-2 |
Lang Sias | CO-7 |
North Carolina | 16% | 8.6% | 75% | 73% | Scott Keadle | NC-10 |
Oklahoma | 16% | 6.7% | 71% | 62% | Kevin Calvey | OK-5 |
South Carolina | 16.1% | 7.8% | 76% | 75% | J. Gresham Barrett | SC-3 |
Jeff Duncan | SC-3 |
U.S. average rate of uninsured 15.40% |
Tennessee | 14.8% | 7.4% | 62% | 62% | Jack Bailey | TN-4 |
Robin Smith | TN-3 |
Virginia | 13.8% | 7% | 83% | 61% | Ben Loyola | VA-2 |
Laurence Verga | VA-5 |
Illinois | 13.2% | 6.1% | 73% | 69% | Bobby Schilling | IL-17 |
Randall Hultgren | IL-14 |
David Ratowitz | IL-5 |
Mark Kirk | IL-10 |
Utah | 13% | 8.3% | 85% | 68% | Jason Chaffetz | UT-3 |
Alabama | 12% | 6.4% | 79% | 88% | Martha Roby | AL-2 |
Mo Brooks | AL-5 |
Georgia | 17.8% | 7.2% | 73% | 69% | Tom Graves | GA-9 |
Steve Tarvin | GA-9 |
Indiana | 11.9% | 6.8% | 83% | 75% | Dan Burton | IN-5 |
Michigan | 11.7% | 5.8% | 78% | 73% | Fred Upton | MI-6 |
Wayne Kuipers | MI-2 |
Ohio | 11.6% | 6.4% | 76% | 58% | Jim Renacci | OH-16 |
Pennsylvania | 9.8% | 5.8% | 86% | N/A | Steve Welch | PA-6 |
Senate lawmakers/candidates petition signers
| Rate Of Uninsurance (2008) | Annual Growth (2008) | Increase In Premiums 2000-2007 | Top 2 Insurers | Lawmaker/ candidate |
U.S. average | 15.4% | 6.7% | 120% | N/A | |
Florida | 20.2% | 7.1% | 72% | 45% | Marco Rubio |
Louisiana | 19.3% | 5.7% | 75% | 74% | David Vitter |
Nevada | 18% | 10% | 57% | 55% | Sharron Angle |
Sue Lowden |
Danny Tarkanian |
Arkansas | 17% | 6.9% | 66% | 81% | Curtis Coleman |
South Carolina | 16.1% | 7.8% | 76% | 75% | Jim DeMint |
Oklahoma | 16% | 6.7% | 71% | 62% | Tom Coburn |
U.S. average rate of uninsured 15.40% |
Kentucky | 14.8% | 7.5% | 48% | 69% | Rand Paul |
Trey Grayson |
Illinois | 13.2% | 6.1% | 73% | 69% | Patrick Hughes |
Utah | 13% | 8.3% | 85% | 68% | Mike Lee |
Tim Bridgewater |
Cherilyn Eagar |
Missouri | 12.6% | 7% | 76% | 79% | Chuck Purgason |
New Hampshire | 10.4% | 7.6% | 79% | 75% | Ovide Lamontagne |
While Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) has previously refused to acknowledge that Republicans would campaign in future elections on a platform of repealing health reform, Newt Gingrich has predicted that "every Republican running in '10 and again in '12 will run on an absolute pledge to repeal" the bill. On Wednesday, Rep. Paul Ryan (R-WI) "encouraged candidates to run on full-scale repeal of health reform" and Reps.Eric Cantor (R-VA) and Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) have indicated that "they will not campaign for full health care repeal but will demand partial repeal, including mandates for health coverage." At least 14 states have announced that they would put the question of repealing reform on the ballot and 17 Attorneys General are also challenging the legislation.
Nick McClellan designed the table for this post.
Cross-posted on The Wonk Room.
http://thinkprogress.org/2010/01/15/rubio-repeal/