Michael Tomasky: A Progressive Defense of the White House on Plan B

I get the reasons for liberal outrage at the Obama administration's Plan B decision. But I can't quite join in the indignation. I know that I am a man—a fact I've been aware of for some time—and so readers male and female can factor that in here as they wish. But it seems to me that to call this merely a case of politics cynically trumping science is way too dismissive of some concerns that parents with all kinds of political views might have about their teenage daughters buying this pill without their knowledge.

Much of the opposition to allowing underage girls to buy the pill over the counter amounts to straw-man arguments. There's the line that taking the pill amounts to abortion. Watch this lurid ad by a right-to-life group and think about what sort of cacophony must be raging inside the mind that could even come up with such an egregious thing. Outside the realm of anti-abortion fanaticism, I don't think most of us would equate the prevention of a pregnancy with the removal of an existing fetus. It's called “emergency contraceptionâ€